Clearly Ambiguous! - Contract Review Series - Contract Australia

Ambiguous or Clear?

I am sure we have all been there, during the project delivery phase, there will be a time where you will hear... "...that is not what we meant." or "...you are misinterpreting the contract" or even "...you should have allowed for that." Ok, well, let us review the contract.

 

What is in this week blog post?

In this four-part blog series focusing on Contract Review practices, I will take you through the high-level items I look out for when reviewing Contracts, Scope of Works, Departure and Clarification Schedules, Responsibility Matrices and more.

 

In part one, I am highlighting the importance of looking for 'Ambiguity' in the contract documentation. I will show you some examples of ambiguity in contracts and demonstrate the remedy. This is one of many ways one can ensure good communication, clear documentation and start to build trust with the other party.

Contract Review

Scope of Works

I am always aware of the Scope of Works document at the tender stage can have some ambiguity because the client may not be fully aware or have knowledge of the details for the package of work. It is why the client is engaging a contractor for the work, to get their expertise. However, the contractor must be aware the ambiguous narrative must be clarified throughout the tender process. For example:

The Subcontractor acknowledges that is has inspected the Site, is aware of and accepts the responsibility for all Site conditions of which it ought to be reasonably aware of and the Subcontract Works must be constructed with due care taking into account those existing Site conditions.

This Scope of Works item is perfectly fine being documented in an RFT or RFQ because it will allow the contractor to assess what information, data, evidence and visual inspection are available and the contractor can clarify. However, this item must not make it into the contract unless the contractor is in fact taking all risk on-site all conditions. If not, clarify what documents, information and data were available, if any geotechnical testing was conducted for example, and what was found on the site inspection. Further, detail out in a schedule what site conditions the contractor is willing to take a risk on. Request the following amendment for example:

The Subcontractor acknowledges that is has inspected the Site and the findings are documented within the site inspection schedule "xxx" completed on date (dd/mm/yy). The contractor is aware of and accepts the responsibility for all Site conditions as per report "yyy" of which it ought to be reasonably aware of and the Subcontract Works must be constructed with due care taking into account those existing Site conditions.

I can hear alarm bells ringing already from both sides of the fence. I am not saying the contractor should not take the risk of existing Site conditions but one must be aware of the risk(s) which allows for the valuation of said risk(s). A further amendment is to schedule out which party is responsible for each site condition if known. I have two personal experiences which come to mind, once we were lucky, the other not so much. So, let's not leave this up to luck.

 

Contract Clauses

In Australia, we tend to use Standard Forms of Contracts, AS4000 family of contracts and GC21 here in NSW for a range of construction, civil engineering, design and construct among others. There are others, of course, NEC3, JCT and FIDIC for our international friends. From recent statistics, 84% of AS Forms of Contracts were amended. Therefore, it is imperative we do not take these for granted, regardless of how long we have worked with them. Here is a straight forward example I found in a contract recently which I believe is ambiguous.

The Contractor may request that any Subcontract Services be tested. The Subcontractor shall provide such assistance and samples and make accessible such part of the Subcontract Services as may be required for such testing. If necessary, on completion of the tests, the Subcontractor shall make good the Subcontract Services in order that they fully comply with the Subcontract.

Let me give you some context, this clause was in a contract for a basement retention package of works, where the subcontractor's works would have been disrupted by testing. In my view, this is an ambiguous clause because it does not clearly articulate or clarify what is to be tested, when, by what standard, to what quality. Further, "make good" wording is open-ended and cannot be quantified, therefore, ambiguous. One might say the keyword here is "Request" which constitutes a direction. Therefore, the subcontractor is entitled to notify the contractor of the direction and notify of a potential variation to the contract. You would be correct, but the clause is still ambiguous.

One way to approach such a clause would be to request the testing to be quantified and clarified through an Inspection and Test Plan for example. Further, any re-work due to works outside of the scope of works must be instructed.

 

Departure, Clarification and Other Return Schedules

My last point of this week's blog is any correspondence which is returned to the client must be clear and not ambiguous. The same way you have reviewed the contract document is the same for the tender schedules in return.

I hope you have found this blog helpful and if you require further clarification please do not hesitate to get in contact with us at www.contractaustralia.com.au or email projects@contractaustralia.com.au or LinkedIn

N.b. Nothing in this article constitutes legal, professional or financial advice.

---

by Garry Andrews

Free AS4000 Contract Templates

Free Contract Templates Exclusive for Contract Australia Subscribers.

Mastering AS4000: Your Ultimate Guide to Contract Administration Templates in Australia

Welcome to the ultimate guide on contract administration templates for AS4000 in Australia! Whether you're a seasoned professional or new to the game, navigating the intricacies of contract administration can be daunting. But fret not, as we've got you covered with expert insights and invaluable resources to help you master AS4000 like a pro.

In this comprehensive guide, we delve into the nitty-gritty of contract administration templates specifically tailored for the Australian market. From understanding the key components of AS4000 to practical tips on implementation, this resource is your go-to companion for streamlining your contract processes and enhancing efficiency.

Get ready to unlock the secrets of effective contract administration with our step-by-step guidance and customisable templates that will empower you to take your projects to new heights. Whether you're a project manager, contract administrator, or legal professional, this guide is designed to elevate your contract management game and maximise success in every endeavour.

Understanding the key components of AS4000

AS4000, officially known as the AS 4000-1997 General Conditions of Contract, serves as a foundational document for construction and engineering projects in Australia. This standard contract form is designed to manage the relationships between parties involved in construction works, including contractors, subcontractors, and clients. One of the key components of AS4000 is its clear delineation of roles and responsibilities, which helps to minimise ambiguities in contractual obligations. Each party's duties are explicitly outlined, ensuring that everyone involved understands their specific contributions and expectations.

Another significant aspect of AS4000 is the incorporation of risk management provisions. The contract addresses how risks are allocated between the parties, which is crucial for determining liability and responsibility in case of unforeseen circumstances. This allocation not only helps foster a collaborative environment but also protects parties from potential disputes that can arise from ambiguous risk-sharing arrangements. Understanding these provisions is essential for effective contract administration and can significantly impact a project's success.

Additionally, AS4000 includes clauses related to payment processes, variations, and dispute-resolution mechanisms. These elements are vital for ensuring that financial transactions are conducted smoothly and that changes to the project scope are managed effectively. The payment clauses outline the timing and conditions for payments, while the variation clauses provide a framework for handling modifications that may arise during the project lifecycle. By familiarising themselves with these key components, contract administrators can navigate the complexities of contract management more efficiently.

Importance of contract administration in Australia

Contract administration plays a pivotal role in the successful delivery of construction projects in Australia. It involves managing contracts to ensure compliance with the terms and conditions agreed upon by all parties. Effective contract administration is crucial for mitigating risks, enhancing communication, and ensuring that projects are completed on time and within budget. By actively monitoring the contract's performance and adherence to its provisions, contract administrators can identify potential issues early on and implement corrective measures before they escalate.

Moreover, contract administration contributes to maintaining strong relationships among stakeholders. In the construction industry, where multiple parties are often involved, clear communication and transparency are essential. By adeptly managing contracts, administrators can facilitate dialogue among clients, contractors, and subcontractors, fostering collaboration and trust. This collaborative approach not only enhances project efficiency but also helps in resolving conflicts amicably, which can save time and resources.

In the Australian context, where regulatory compliance and industry standards are stringent, the importance of contract administration cannot be overstated. Proper administration ensures that all legal obligations are met, reducing the likelihood of disputes and legal challenges. This is particularly important in a highly regulated sector, where a failure to comply with contractual and legal requirements can lead to severe penalties and reputational damage. Therefore, understanding the significance of robust contract administration practices is essential for anyone involved in the construction industry in Australia.

Benefits of using contract administration templates

Utilising contract administration templates offers numerous advantages for professionals managing construction projects. One of the primary benefits is the significant time savings they provide. By having a ready-made structure, contract administrators can quickly develop contracts that meet specific project requirements without starting from scratch. This efficiency not only expedites the contract creation process but also allows professionals to focus on other critical aspects of project management.

Another noteworthy benefit of using templates is the consistency they bring to contract administration. Templates ensure that standard terms and clauses are included in every contract, which helps maintain uniformity across various projects. This consistency is particularly beneficial for organisations that manage multiple contracts simultaneously, as it minimises the risk of errors and omissions. Additionally, having a standardised approach fosters familiarity among stakeholders, making it easier for them to understand and comply with contractual obligations.

Furthermore, contract administration templates can enhance compliance with legal and regulatory requirements. Many templates are designed to align with industry standards and best practices, ensuring that all necessary provisions are included. This alignment reduces the likelihood of legal disputes arising from ambiguous or incomplete contracts. By leveraging these templates, contract administrators can ensure that their contracts are not only practical but also compliant with the relevant laws and regulations in Australia.

Overview of AS4000 contract administration templates

AS4000 contract administration templates are tailored documents designed to streamline contract administration based on the AS4000 framework. These templates typically include standard clauses, terms, and conditions aligned with the AS4000 guidelines, making them invaluable resources for construction industry professionals. They can cover various aspects of contract administration, including risk allocation, payment schedules, and dispute resolution processes, providing a comprehensive tool for managing contracts effectively.

One of the key features of AS4000 templates is their flexibility. While they offer a standardised structure, they can also be customised to suit a project's specific needs. This adaptability is crucial in the construction sector, where every project is unique and may require tailored clauses to address particular risks or requirements. By using these templates, contract administrators can ensure that they meet both the general expectations set by AS4000 and the unique demands of their projects.

In addition to saving time and enhancing compliance, AS4000 templates often come with built-in best practices for contract administration. They may include checklists or guiding notes to assist users in understanding the purpose of each clause and its implications. This educational component can be particularly beneficial for those who are new to contract administration or seeking to improve their knowledge of the AS4000 framework. By providing a comprehensive overview of key considerations, these templates empower professionals to manage their contracts with greater confidence and expertise.

Step-by-step guide to using AS4000 templates

To effectively utilise AS4000 contract administration templates, it is essential to follow a structured approach. The first step involves selecting the appropriate template based on the specific project requirements. Consider factors such as the type of project, the parties involved, and any unique risks or challenges that may arise. By ensuring that the selected template aligns with the project's needs, administrators can lay a solid foundation for successful contract management.

Once the template is selected, the next step is to customise it to reflect the specific terms and conditions relevant to the project. This process may involve modifying or adding clauses to address particular risks, payment terms, or project milestones. It is crucial to involve all relevant stakeholders in this process to ensure that their interests and obligations are accurately represented in the contract. Collaboration during this phase can help prevent misunderstandings and conflicts later in the project lifecycle.

After customisation, the contract should be thoroughly reviewed and finalised before execution. This review process is critical for identifying any potential issues or ambiguities that could lead to disputes down the line. Engaging legal professionals or contract specialists during this phase can provide an additional layer of assurance, ensuring that the contract complies with all legal requirements and accurately reflects the intentions of the parties involved. Once all parties are satisfied, the agreement can be executed, marking the beginning of the project.

Common challenges in contract administration and how to overcome them

Contract administration is fraught with challenges that can impede the successful execution of construction projects. One common challenge is the lack of clarity in contract terms, which can lead to misunderstandings among parties. Ambiguous clauses may result in different interpretations, causing disputes that can stall project progress. To mitigate this risk, it is essential to use clear and precise language when drafting contracts. Engaging legal experts during the contract formulation process can also help identify potential ambiguities and ensure that all terms are easily understandable.

Another challenge faced in contract administration is managing changes to the project scope. Variations are common in construction projects due to unforeseen circumstances, but they can complicate contract management if not appropriately handled. To address this challenge, it is vital to establish a transparent process for managing variations when using AS4000 templates. This process should outline how changes are proposed, assessed, and approved, ensuring that all parties are on the same page regarding modifications to the contract.

Additionally, effective communication is crucial for overcoming challenges in contract administration. Poor communication can lead to delays, misunderstandings, and, ultimately, disputes. To foster open lines of communication, regular meetings and updates should be scheduled among all stakeholders. Establishing a culture of transparency and collaboration can significantly enhance project outcomes and reduce the likelihood of conflicts arising from misunderstandings or miscommunications.

Training resources for mastering AS4000 contract administration

To excel in AS4000 contract administration, ongoing training and education are essential. Various resources are available to help professionals deepen their understanding of the AS4000 framework and improve their contract management skills. Online courses and webinars offered by industry associations and educational institutions provide a flexible way to learn about contract administration principles, best practices, and the specific nuances of AS4000.

Additionally, attending workshops and seminars can offer valuable hands-on experience and networking opportunities with industry peers. These events often feature expert speakers who share insights and real-world experiences related to contract administration. Engaging in discussions with fellow professionals can also provide different perspectives on common challenges and practical solutions, enriching one's understanding of the subject matter.

Moreover, numerous publications and reference materials are dedicated to AS4000 and contract administration. Books, articles, and industry reports can serve as excellent resources for both novice and experienced practitioners. These materials often cover case studies, practical examples, and detailed analyses of contract administration practices, enabling readers to apply theoretical knowledge to practical scenarios effectively. By leveraging these training resources, individuals can enhance their expertise in AS4000 contract administration and contribute to more successful project outcomes.

Contract administration services in Australia

In Australia, various contract administration services are available to assist organisations and professionals in managing their construction contracts effectively. These services encompass a wide range of offerings, including contract drafting, negotiation, and ongoing administration throughout the project lifecycle. Engaging professional contract administrators can help organisations navigate the complexities of AS4000 and ensure that their contracts are compliant with legal requirements and industry standards.

One key benefit of utilising contract administration services is access to specialised expertise. Professional contract administrators possess in-depth knowledge of the AS4000 framework and can provide valuable insights into best practices for contract management. They can assist in tailoring contracts to meet specific project needs, ensuring that all relevant terms and conditions are adequately addressed. This expertise is particularly beneficial for organisations lacking in-house resources or experience in contract administration.

Additionally, contract administration services can help organisations streamline their processes and improve efficiency. These services often include implementing contract management software, which can automate various tasks, such as tracking milestones, managing payments, and monitoring compliance with contractual obligations. By leveraging technology, organisations can enhance their contract administration capabilities, reduce the risk of errors, and ultimately achieve better project outcomes.

Conclusion and key takeaways

In conclusion, mastering AS4000 and effective contract administration is crucial for the success of construction projects in Australia. Understanding the key components of AS4000, recognising the importance of contract administration, and leveraging templates can significantly enhance project efficiency and mitigate risks. The benefits of using contract administration templates, including time savings and consistency, cannot be overstated.

As professionals navigate the challenges of contract administration, it is essential to adopt a structured approach when using AS4000 templates. Clear communication, thorough review processes, and effective change management strategies are vital for overcoming common obstacles. Furthermore, investing in training resources and engaging professional contract administration services can provide invaluable support and expertise.

Ultimately, by prioritising effective contract administration and leveraging the resources available, professionals can significantly improve their project outcomes and contribute to the overall success of the construction industry in Australia. Embracing these practices will not only enhance individual capabilities but also foster a culture of collaboration and accountability among all stakeholders involved.

---

by Garry Andrews

Indemnity… …What a Liability! - Contract Review Series - Contract Australia

Might as well just give my business away!

When reviewing a contract one of the first places I look in the Contract is Indemnity. Some of you ready this will know exactly why. For those who do not, it is because we need to understand the level of risk the business is being exposed to in the unlikely event of an incident. If you do not cap the indemnity, define parameters and cross-reference with insurances, you might as well just give your business away.

 

What is in this week's blog post?

In this four-part blog series focusing on Contract Review practices, I will take you through the high-level items I look out for when reviewing Contracts, Scope of Works, Departure and Clarification Schedules, Responsibility Matrices and more.

In part two, I am highlighting the importance of understanding 'Indemnity' in the contract documentation. I will show you an example of an Indemnity Clause in contracts and demonstrate the remedy.

 

Contract Review

Contract Clauses

In Australia, we tend to use Standard Forms of Contracts, AS4000 family of contracts and GC21 here in NSW for a range of construction, civil engineering, design and construct among others. There are others, of course, NEC3, JCT and FIDIC for our international friends. From recent statistics, 84% of AS Forms of Contracts were amended. Therefore, it is imperative we do not take these for granted, regardless of how long we have worked with them. Here is a straight forward example of an Indemnity clause found in a contract recently:

The Subcontractor is liable for and indemnifies and shall keep indemnified the Contractor (to the maximum extent permitted by law) against:

(a) all cost, loss, damage and expense (including legal fees on an indemnity bases) suffered by the Contractor and any of its employees or agents; and

(b) all liabilities incurred by the Contractor as a consequence of any liability the Contractor has or may have to the Principal or another third party in relation to, arising out of or in connection with the Head Contract, the work under the Head Contract or work under a separate subcontract or consultancy agreement,arising directly or indirectly as a result of or in connection with the performance of the Subcontractor's obligations under this Subcontract, any breach of Subcontract by or any negligence of the Subcontractor, its employees, secondary subcontractors or agents. However, the Subcontractor’s liability to indemnify the Contractor, its employees, or agents is reduced proportionally to the extent that the act or omission of the Contractor, its employees or agents caused or contributed to the cost, loss, damage, expense or liability.

 

The issue for me is the "all" costs and "indirectly" as a result of the Subcontractors obligations. For me, this is too open-ended, subjective, in fact! Therefore, needs to be defined and capped.

One way to approach such a clause would be to request the indemnity to be capped at X% of the contract value and set parameters. I have given an example of how this clause can be amended to ensure there is some cap to the liability.

The Subcontractor shall indemnify the Main Contractor against foreseeable costs relating to the following which were caused by negligent acts or omissions of the Subcontractor:

(a) loss of or damage to the Contractor’s property; and

(b) claims in respect of personal injury or death, arising out of or as a consequence of the carrying out of the Subcontract Works, but the indemnity shall be reduced proportionally to the extent that the act or omission of the Principal, the Contractor or the consultants, agents or other Contractors (not being employed by the Subcontractor) of the Principal or the Contractor may have contributed to the injury, death, loss or damage and/or the Contractor failed to reasonably mitigate the injury, death, loss or damage.

This subclause shall not apply to:

i. the extent that the Subcontractor’s liability is limited by another provision of the Subcontract;

ii. damage which is the unavoidable result of the construction of the Subcontract Works in accordance with the Subcontract”

(c) the Subcontractor shall indemnify the Contractor againsts foreseeable costs capped at the value set out in "Item X in Schedule 1 of the Contract" (Input Item and Set % of Contract Value in Schedule 1)

The main point of this blog is for construction professionals to make a concerted effort to fully understand the Indemnity Clause. If the clause raises the risk exposure to the business, one must try to negotiate the Indemnity Clause in Contracts. It will limit the liability and protect the business you are working for. There is one thing for sure you do not want this to be open-ended as you might as well just give your business away.

Departure, Clarification and Other Return Schedules

My last point of this week's blog is any correspondence which is returned to the client must be clear and not ambiguous. The same way you have reviewed the contract document is the same for the tender schedules in return.

I hope you have found this blog helpful and if you require further clarification please do not hesitate to get in contact with us at www.contractaustralia.com.au or email projects@contractaustralia.com.au or LinkedIn

N.b. Nothing in this article constitutes legal, professional or financial advice.

---

by Garry Andrews